Giving Preference (Tarjih) Between Texts With Attribution: Reffering To Narrators Standards

الترجيح بين النصوص بالإسناد: مرجحات تعود إلى الراوي أنموذجًا

  • Muhammad Said Al-Mujahed Associate Professor
Keywords: Tarjih, Scholars, Texts, Narrators, Chain

Abstract

This paper was intended to explain on giving preference or outweighing (Tarjih) methods used in determination between legal texts. There’s few questioned that have been touched on this paper like, what is the reality truth of Tarjih? What is the common methods used by scholars in Tarjih between texts? What is the specific preference reason applied on the narrators? And, is there any examples of that? This research was completed by using analytical inductive methodology and the finding of the study can be concluded as follows; linguist used the word ‘outweigh’ with definition revolve around the meaning of  ‘added in something’. Outweighing means strengthening one of the two guides by giving preference to them. Scholars have restricted the methods of outweighing into; weightings based on chain of narrators, weightings based on the narration itself, or what it is narrated, or what’s it narrated from it. In conclusion, this study highlighting some important points which brings to concern in compilation of conflicting texts and reminding as well explaining on the techniques of Tarjih.

 

ملخص البحث

هدفت الدراسة إلى بيان طرق الترجيح بين النصوص، فتطرقت إلى السؤال عن حقيقة الترجيح؟ وما الطرق التي يسلكها العلماء للترجيح بين النصوص عمومًا؟ وما المرجحات التي تعود إلى الراوي خصوصًا؟ وهل توجد أمثلة لذلك؟ وتم استخدام المنهج الاستقرائي التحليلي، وأظهرت الدراسة نتائج لعل من أهمها؛ استعمل أهل اللغة كلمة رجح بمعان تدور حول معنى الزيادة في الشيء. إن الترجيح هو تقوية أحد الدليلين بوجه من وجوه الترجيح الآتي بعضها فيكون راجحًا. حصر العلماء طرق الترجيح بين النصوص، وقسموها إلى: ترجيحات عائدة إلى الإسناد، ترجيحات تعود إلى نفس الرواية، أو المروي، أو المروي عنه.

Author Biography

Muhammad Said Al-Mujahed , Associate Professor

Islamic Sciences Department, College of Education, Sultan Qaboos University.

References

Abu Dawud, Sulaiman Bin al-Asy‘ath al-Sajistani. Isyraf: al-Sheikh Solih Bin Abdul Aziz Ali Syaikh. 1999. Sunan Abi Dawud. Dar al-Salam. Riyadh. Dar al-Fehaa’: Damsyiq.

Abu Zur‘ah, Abdul Rahman Bin Muhammad Bin Zanjalah. 1982. Hujjah al-Qira’at. Tahqiq: Saed al-Afghaniy. Muassasah al-Risalah: Beirut.

al-Aamidi, Muhammad Bin Ismail. 1984. Ihkam al-Ahkam. Tahqiq: Dr. Saed al-Jamiliy. Dar al-Kitab al-Arabiy: Beirut.

al-Baidhawi, Abdullah Bin Umar Bin Muhammad. 1989. Manhaj al-Wusul Ila Ilm al-Usul. Tahqiq: Sulaim Syub‘aniah. Dar Raniah: Damsyiq.

al-Basri, Abu al-Hussain Muhammad Bin Ali Bin Al-Thaib. 1983. al-Mu’tamad. Tahqiq: Khalil al-Mais. Dar al-Kutb al-Ilmiah: Beirut.

al-Bazdawiy. Abdul Aziz Bin Ahmad Bin Muhammad. 1997. Usul al-Bazdawi. Dabt: Muhammad al-Mu’tasim Billah al-Baghdadi. Dar al-Kitab al-‘Arabiy: Beirut.

al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail. 1999. Sahih al-Bukhari. Dar al-Faihaa: Damsyiq.

al-Dahlawi, Waliyullah Ahmad Bin Abdul Rahim. n.d. al-Inshaf Fil Ikhtilaf. Tahqiq: Abdul Fatah Abu Ghuddah. Dar al-Nafais: Beirut.

al-Fairuzabadi, Majiduddin Muhammad Bin Ya’akub. 1994. Qamus al-Muhit. Tahqiq: Maktab Tahqiq al-Turath Fi Muassasah al-Risalah Bi Isyraf al-Syaikh Muhammad Na‘em ‘Arqasusi. Muasasah al-Risalah: Beirut.

al-Farahidi, al-Khalil Bin Ahmad. 1990. al-‘Ain. Tahqiq: Dr. Mahdi al-Makhzumi & Dr. Ibrahim al-Saamiraie. Maktabah al-Hilal: Saudiah.

al-Futuhi, Abu al-Baqa’ Taqiyuddin Muhammad Bin Ahmad. n.d. Syarah al-Kawakibul Munir. Matbaah Sunnah al-Mahmudiah: n.p.

al-Ghazali, Muhammad Bin Muhammad Abu Hamid. 1992. al-Mustasfa. Tahqiq: Muhammad Abdul Salam Abdul Syaafi. Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiah: Beirut.

al-Haazimi, Abu Bakar Muhammad Bin Musa Bin Uthman. 1940. al-‘Itibar Fi al-Nasikh Wa al-Mansukh Min Aathar. Hayderabad.

al-Isnawi, Abdul Rahim Bin al-Hasn. 1980. al-Tamhid. Tahqiq: Dr. Muhammad Hasan Hetoo. Muassasah. Beirut: Lebanon.

al-Isnawi, Jamal al-Din Abdul Rahim. n.d. Syarh al-Isnawi ‘Ala Manhaj al-Wusul Fi ‘Ilm al-Usul. Dar al-Kutb al-Ilmiah: Beirut

Ibn Hibban, Muhammad al-Tamimi. 1993. Sahih Ibn Hibban Bi Tartib Ibn Balban. Tahqiq: Shu‘aib al-Arna‘ut. Muassasah al-Risalah: Beirut.

al-Humaidi, Abdullah Bin al-Zubair al-Humaidi. 1996. al-Musnad. Dar al-Saqa: Damsyiq.

al-Juwayni. Abul Ma‘ali Abdul Malik Bin Abdullah Bin Yusof. 1997. al-Burhan Fi Usul al-Fiqh. Tahqiq: Dr. Abdul Azim Mahmood al-Dib. Dar al-Wafa’: Mansuroh.

al-Khin. Mustofa Saed. 1989. Athar al-Ikhtilaf Fi al-Qawaid al-Usuliah Fi Ikhtilaf al-Fuqaha’. Muassasah Risalah: Beirut.

al-Qurafi, Shihabuddin Abi al-Abas Ahmad Bin Idris. 1889. Syarah Tanqih al-Fusul Fil Usul. Matbaah Khairiyyah: Misr.

al-Mubarakfuri, Abu al-‘Ala Muhammad Abdul Rahman Bin Abdul Rahim. 1990. Tuhfah al-Ahwadzi. Dar Kutub al-Ilmiah: Beirut.

al-Nasa’ie, Ahmad Bin Syu‘aib. 1999. Sunan al-Nasa’ie al-Sughro. Isyraf: al-Syeikh Solih Bin Abdul Aziz Aali Syaikh. Dar Salam: Riyadh.

al-Nawawi, Yahya Bin Syarif. 1972. Syarah al-Nawawi Ala Sohih al-Imam Muslim. Dar Ihya’ Turath al-‘Arabi: Beirut.

al-Nawawi, Yahya Bin Syarif. 1988. Irsyad Tulab al-Haqaiq Ila Ma’rifah Sunan Khair al-Kholaiq. Tahqiq: Dr. Nuruddin ‘Atir. Matba‘ah al-Ittihad: Damsyiq.

al-Raazi, Muhammad Bin Abi Bakar. 1992. Ghayah al-Usul Syarah Labb al-Usul. Tartib: Mahmud Khatir. Tahqiq: Hamzah Fathullah. Muassasah Risalah: Beirut.

al-Raazi, Fakhruddin Muhammad Bin Umar. 1992. al-Mahshul Fi Ilm Usul al-Fiqh. Tahqiq: Dr. TaahaJabir al-‘llwani. Muassasah al-Risalah: Beirut.

al-Sarakhsi, Abu Bakar Muhammad Bin Ahmad Bin Abi Sahl. 1953. Usul al-Sarakhsi. Tahqiq: Abu al-Wafa al-Afghani. Dar al-Ma’rifah: Beirut.

al-Subki, Qadhi Ali Bin Abdul Kaafi. 1984. al-Ibhaj Syarah al-Minhaj. Dar al-Kutub Ilmiah: Beirut.

al-Suyuti, Abdul Rahman Bin Abi Bakar. 1979. Tadrib al-Rawi Fi Syarh Taqrib an-Nawawi. Tahqiq: Abdul Wahab Abdul Latif. Dar Ihya’ al-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah: Beirut.

al-Syaukani, Muhammad Bin Ali Bin Muhammad. 1992. Irsyad al-Fuhul. Tahqiq: Muhammad Bin Saed al-Badri. Dar al-Fikr: Beirut.

al-Syafie, Muhammad Bin Idris. 1939. al-Risalah. Tahqiq: Ahmaad Muhammad Syakir. n.pb: Qaherah.

al-Tirmidhi, Muhammad Bin Isa. 1999. Sunan al-Tirmidhi. Isyraf: al-Syeikh Solih Bin Abdul Aziz Aali Syaikh. Dar al-Faiha’: Damsyiq.

al-Tuftazani, Saaduddin. 1957. Syarh al-Talwih Ala al-Taudhih Li Matn al-Tanqih Fi Usul al-Fiqh. Matba’ah Muhammad Ali Subaih Wa Awladuhu: Qaherah.

Ibn Abdul Bar, Abu Umar Tusuf al-Namri. 1967. al-Tamhid Li Ma Fi al-Muwatta’ Min al-Maaniy Wal Asanid. Tahqiq: Musthafa Bin Ahmad al-Alawi & Muhammad Abdul Kabir al-Bakri. Wizarah Umum al-Awqaf Wal Syu’un al-Islamiyyah. Maghribi.

Ibn Amir al-Hajj, Shamsuddin Muhammad Bin Muhammad. 1996. al-Taqrir Wa al-Tahbir. Dar al-Fikr: Beirut.

Ibn Badran, Abdul Qadir al-Dimasyqiy. 1981. al-Madkhal. Tahqiq: Abdullah Bin Abdul Muhsin al-Turki. Muassasah Risalah: Beirut.

Ibn Jawzi, Abu al-Farj Abdul Rahman Bin Ali Bin Muhammad. 2006. al-Tahqiq Fi Ahadith al-Khilaf. Tahqiq: Mas‘ud Abdul Hamid Muhammad al-Sa’dani. Dar al-Kutb al-Ilmiah: Beirut.

Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, Abu al-Fadl Ahmad Bin Ali. 1993. Nazha al-Nadhr Fi Taudih al-Fikar Fi Mustholah Ahl Al-Athar. Tahqiq: Dr. Nuruddin ‘Atir. Dar al-Khair: Damsyiq.

Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, Abu al-Fadl Ahmad Bin Ali. 1959. Fath al-Baari Syarh Sahih al-Bukhari. Tahqiq: Muhammad Fuad Abdul Baaqi & Muhibbuddin al-Khatib. Dar al-Ma’rifah: Beirut.

Ibn Hajar al-Haitami, Shihabuddin Ahmad. 1987. al-Manhaj al-Qawim ‘Ala al-Muqaddimah al-Hadramiah. Tahqiq: Dr. Musthafa al-Khin Wa Akhorun. Dar al-Faihaa’. Oman.

Ibn Hanbal, Ahmad. 2001. Musnad Imam Ahmad. Dar al-Ma‘arif: Misr.

Ibn Majah, Abu Abdullah Muhammad Bin Yazid al-Qazwini. 1999. Sunan Ibn Majah. Isyraf: al-Syaikh Solih Bin Abdul Aziz Ali Syaikh. Dar Salam: Riyadh.

Ibn Manzur, Muhammad Bin Mukarram. 1993. Lisan al-‘Arab. Dar Sadir: Beirut.

Ibn Qudamah, Abdullah Bin Ahmad al-Maqdisi. 1979. Raudhatul Naadhir Wa Junnatul Manadhir. Tahqiq: Abdul Azizi Abdul Rahman al-Saed. Jaamiah al-Imam Muhammad Bin Saud: Riyadh.

Malik Bin Anas Bin Malik Bin Aamir al-Ashbahi al-Madani. 1988. al-Muwatta’. Dar Ihya’ Ulum: Beirut.

Muslim, Muslim Bin Hujaj al-Naisaburi. 1998. Sahih Muslim. Dar Salam: Riyadh.

Published
2020-06-30
How to Cite
Al-Mujahed , M. S. (2020). Giving Preference (Tarjih) Between Texts With Attribution: Reffering To Narrators Standards. Al-Qanatir: International Journal of Islamic Studies, 19(1), 98-118. Retrieved from http://al-qanatir.com/index.php/aq/article/view/271