The Academic Improprieties Committed In Book Titled Al-Shafi’S Offence For Zakaria Ozone: Descriptive And Analytical Study

المخالفات العلميّة في كتاب جناية الشّافعي لزكريا أوزون: دراسة وصفية تحليلية

  • Al Mughira Hamzeh Said Mahmood Ph.D Student
  • Wan Mohd Yusof Wan Chik Associate Professor
  • Zulkifli Mohamad Lecturer
  • Khiral Anuar Daud Lecturer
Keywords: Academic, Improprieties, al-Shafi’, Offence, Zakaria Ozon

Abstract

This paper deals with the academic improprieties which Zakaria Ozone committed in his book titled “Al-Shafi’s Offence, Delivering the Nation from the Imam’s Jurisprudence”. His book criticizes Jurisprudence and its foundations; and as it is clear from the title of the book, the aim from authoring it was to salvage the Muslims from Jurisprudence. Hence, he launched a scathing attack on Jurisprudence and its foundations by targeting al-Shafi’ in his quality as a leading scholar of Jurisprudence and as the pioneer in compiling the science of jurisprudence foundations and in establishing the principles and protocols of dealing with Shari‘ah texts. The paper aims to expound the main points listed on the book titled “Al-Shafi’s Offence” in terms of the contraventions of the basics and regulations of scientific research. The method adopted in this paper is descriptive and analytical; it expounds the most flagrant scientific and methodological contradictions the author has fallen into. It is a theoretic desk study that has concluded that Zakaria Ozone has contradicted in his book “Al-Shafi’s Offence” the principles of scientific research; his book lacked objectivity and scientific integrity in several passages. He made several allegations without any evidence; he even attributed to al-Shafi’ a host of opinions which al-Shafi’ adopts their opposite, not to mention his confusion and double standards.

ملخص البحث

يتناول هذا البحث المخالفات العلميّة التي وقع فيها زكريا أوزون في كتابه "جناية الشّافعي تخليص الأمة من فقه الأئمة" وهو كتاب يتناول الفقه وأصوله بالنقد وكما هو واضح من عنوان الكتاب فالغاية من تأليفه هو تخليص المسلمين من الفقه؛ لذلك فقد هاجم الفقه وأصوله من خلال الشّافعي بوصفه علمًا من أعلام الفقه وبوصفه أولَّ من دون علم الأصول ودوّن القواعد والضوابط للتعامل مع النصوص الشّرعية. ويهدف البحث إلى بيان أهم ما ورد في كتاب "جناية الشّافعي" من مخالفات لأصول وضوابط البحث العلمي. والمنهج المتبع في هذا البحث هو المنهج الوصفي التحليلي وذلك بعرض أهم المخالفات العلميّة المنهجيّة التي وقع فيها صاحب الكتاب، ونوع الدّراسة مكتبية نظريّة. وخلصت الدّراسة إلى مخالفة زكريا أوزون في كتابه "جناية الشّافعي" لأصول البحث العلمي، فقد خالف الموضوعيّة والأمانة العلميّة في كثير من المواضع، وادعى ادعاءات كثيرة دون بيّنة، بل نسب للشّافعي أقوالًا والشّافعي يصرّح بخلافها، هذا غير تناقضه وكيله بمكيالين.

Author Biographies

Al Mughira Hamzeh Said Mahmood, Ph.D Student

Faculty of Islamic Contemporary Studies, Sultan Zainal Abidin University

Wan Mohd Yusof Wan Chik, Associate Professor

Research Institute for Products and Islamic Civilization (INSPIRE), Sultan Zainal Abidin University

Zulkifli Mohamad, Lecturer

Department of Syariah, Faculty of Islamic Contemporary Studies, Sultan Zainal Abidin University

Khiral Anuar Daud, Lecturer

Department of Syariah, Faculty of Islamic Contemporary Studies, Sultan Zainal Abidin University

References

Abu Al-Hija’, Dr. Yasin. 2007. Qira’ah Dilaliyyah Fi Kitab “Zakariyya Auzun”, “Jinayah Sibawaih” ,“ Al-Fard Al-Taam Lamma Fi Nahw Min Auham”. Urdun: Majallah Majma’ Al-Lughah Al-‘Arabiyyah Al-Urduni. Al-‘Adad 72.
Ali ‘Abdul Qadir, ‘Abdul Rahman bin Ahmad. 2019. Jinayah Zakariyya Auzun ‘Ala Al-Imam Al-Shafi‘i : Nazarat Naqdiyyah Fi Kitab Jinayah Al-Shafi‘i Li Zakariyya Auzun. Kuwayt: Rawasikh.
Al-Asfahani, Abu Al-Qasim Al-Hussin bin Muhammad. 1991. Al-Mufradat Fi Gharib Al-Quran. Dimashq-Bayrut: Dar Al-Qalam, Al-Dar Al-Shamiah.
Auzun, Zakariyya. 2007. Hal Al-Islam Huwa Al-Hillu? Bayrut: Riyad Al-Riis Li Al-Kutb Wa Al-Nashr.
Auzun, Zakariyya. 2004. Jinayah Al-Bukhari Inqaz Al-Din Min Imam Al-Muhaddithin. Bayrut: Riyad Al-Riis Li Al-Kutb Wa Al-Nashr.
Auzun, Zakariyya. 2005. Jinayah Al-Shafi‘i Takhlis Al-Ummah Min Fiqh Al-A’immah. Bayrut: Riyad Al-Riis Li Al-Kutb Wa Al-Nashr.
Auzun, Zakariyya. 2002. Jinayah Sibawaih Al-Fard Al-Tam Lamma Fi Nahw Min Auham. Bayrut: Riyad Al-Riis Li Al-Kutb Wa Al-Nashr.
Auzun, Zakariyya. 2008. Laffiq Al-Muslimun Iz Qalu. Bayrut: Riyad Al-Riis Li Al-Kutb Wa Al-Nashr.
Al-Bahithun Al-Muslimun, Majmu‘ah Min Al-‘Ulama Muslimin Fi ‘Ulum Al-‘Ilmiyyah. 2015. Injazat Muslimin Fi Al-‘Asr Al-Hadith. https://muslims-res.com/books/
Al-Baqilani, Abu Bakar Muhammad bin Al-Tayyib. 1997. I’jaz Al-Quran Li Al-Baqilani. Misr: Dar Al-Ma‘arif, Taba‘ah 5.
Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Isma‘il Abu ‘Abdullah. 2001. Al-Jami’ Al-Musnad Al-Sahih Al-Mukhtasar Min Umur Rasulillah Salla Allah ‘Alaih Wasallam Wa Sunanihi Wa Ayyamihi : Sahih Al-Bukhari. Bayrut: Dar Tauq Al-Nujah.
Brinton, Karen. 2004. Tasykil Al-‘Aql Al-Hadith. Tarjamah: Shauqi Jalal. Al-Qahirah: Dar Al-‘Ain Li Al-Nashr.
Diuranat, William James. 1988. Qissah Al-Hadharah. Bayrut: Dar Al-Jil. Tunis: Al-Manzimah Al-‘Arabiyyah Li Al-Tarbiyyah Wa Al-Thaqafah Wa Al-‘Ulum.
Farshawh, Dr Muhammad Amin. 1996. Mausu‘ah ‘Abaqarah Al-Islam Fi Ilm Wa Al-Fikr Wa Al-Adab Wa Al-Qiyadah. Bayrut: Dar Fikr Al-‘Arabiy.
Ibn Faris Abu Al-Husin Ahmad bin Faris bin Zakariyya’. 1978. Mu’jam Maqayis Al-Lughah. Bayrut: Dar Al-Fikr.
Ibn Hisyam, ‘Abd Al-Malik bin Hisham bin Ayub, Abu Muhammad, Jamaluddin. 1955. Al-Sirah Al-Nabawiyyah Li Ibn Hisyam. Misr: Syirkah Maktabah Wa Matba‘ah Mustafa Al-Babi Al-Halbi Wa Auladuhu. Taba‘ah 3.
Ibn Al-Jazari, Shams Al-Din Abu Al-Khair Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Yusuf. N.d. Al-Nashr Fi Al-Qiraat Al-Ashr. Misr: Al-Matba‘ah Al-Tijariyyah Al-Kubra.
Ibn Manzur, Muhammad bin Mukram bin Ali, Abu Al-Fadl. 1993. Lisanul ‘Arab. Bayrut: Dar Sadir, Taba‘ah 3.
Ibn Al-Qayyim, Muhammad bin Abi Bakr bin Ayyub bin Saad Shams Al-Din. 1991. I’lam Al-Muwafi‘in An Rabb Al-‘Alamin. Bayrut: Dar Al-Kutb Al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Ibn Sayyiduhu, Abu Al-Hasan ‘Ali Bin Isma‘il. 2000. Al-Muhkam Wa Al-Muhbit Al-A’zom. Bayrut: Dar Al-Kutb Al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Jarishah Wa Al-Zabiq, Ali Muhammad Wa Muhammad Sharif. 1978. Asalib Al-Ghazw Al-Fikri Li Al-A’lam Al-Islam. Misr: Dar Al-Wafa’, Taba‘ah 3.
Al-Juwaini, ‘Abd Al-Malik bin ‘Abd Allah bin Yusuf bin Muhammad, Abu Al-Ma‘ali, Rukn Al-Din, Al-Mulqab Bi Imam Al-Haramain. 1997. Al-Burhan Fi Usul Fiqh. Bayrut: Dar Al-Kutb Al-‘Ilmiyyah.
Mahmud, Al-Mughirah Hamzah Sa‘id. 2020. Kitab Jinayah Al-Shafi‘i Li Zakariyya Auzun: Dirasah Naqdiyyah Fi Mizan ‘Ilm Usul Fiqh. Terengganu: Jami‘ah Sultan Zain Al-‘Abidin, Quddimat Hazihi Al-Risalah Li Al-Husul ‘Ala Darjah Majister Fi Shari‘ah Bi Kulliyyah Dirasat Islamiyyah Al-Mu‘asirah.
Al-Mazrou‘i, Akram Ali Mus‘ad. 2013. Al-Khuttab Al-Islamiy Al-Waqi’ Wa Al-Tajdid. Risalah Muqaddimah Ila Majlis Kulliyyah Tarbiyyah Adn. Jumhuriyyah Yamaniyyah: Jami‘ah ‘Adn, Li Istikmal Mutatallibat Nail Darajah Majister Fi Dirasat Al-Islamiyyah Takhassus Fikr Al-Islamiy.
Muslim, Muslim bin Al-Hajaj Abu Al-Hassan. N.d. Al-Musnad Al-Sahih Al-Mukhtasar Bi Naql Al-‘Adl Ila Rasulillah Salla Allah ‘Alaih Wasallam. Bayrut: Dar Ihya Al-Turath Al-‘Arabiy.
Al-Nubhani, Taqi Al-Din. N.d. Al-Shakhsiyyah Al-Islamiyyah. Al-Quds: Min Manshurat Hizb Tahrir.
Al-Shafi‘i, Abu Abd Allah Muhammad bin Idris bin Al-‘Abbas bin ‘Uthman. 1939. Al-Risalah. Misr: Maktabah Al-Halbi.
Al-Shatibi, Ibrahim bin Musa bin Muhammad. 1996. Al-Muwafaqat. Al-Qahirah: Dar Ibn ‘Affan.
Al-Suyuti, ‘Abd Al-Rahman bin Abi Bakr, Jalal Al-Din. N.d. Tadrib Al-Rawi Fi Sharh Taqrib Al-Nawawi. Riyad: Dar Tayyibah.
Al-Tabari, Muhammad bin Jarir Bin Yazid. 1999. Jami’ Al-Bayan Fi Ta’wil Al-Qur’an. Bayrut: Muassasah Al-Risalah.
Taqrir Qanah Al-Hirrah ‘Indama Istidafatihi Fi Barnamij “Mukhtalif ‘Alaih” : https://twitter.com/alhurranews/status/1070418079199449088 . Wa Min Safhatihi ‘Ala Twitter : https://twitter.com/zakouzon?lang=ar
Al-Tawil, Sayyid Rizq. N.d. Muqaddimah Fi Usul Al-Bahth Al-‘Ilmi Wa Tahqiq Turath. Misr: Al-Maktabah Al-Azhariyyah Lil Turath, Taba‘ah 2.
Yusuf, Yusuf Hasan. 2016. Dima’a ‘Ala Abwab Al-Mawasid Ightiyalat ‘Ulama Al-‘Arab. Al-Qahirah: Sima Li Al-Nashr Wa Al-Tauzi’.
Al-Zahabi, Shams Al-Din Abu ‘Abd Allah Muhammad bin Ahmad bin ‘Uthman. 1985. Siiru Al-A’lam Al-Nubala’. Bayrut: Muassasah Al-Risalah, Taba‘ah 3.
Al-Zamakhsyariy, Abu Qasim Mahmud bin Amru bin Ahmad. 1986. Al-Kasyaf An Haqaiq Ghawamid Al-Tanzil. Bayrut: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabiy. Taba‘ah 3.
Al-Zarkashiy, Abu ‘Abd Allah Badr Al-Din Muhammad bin ‘Abd Allah. 1994. Al-Bahr Al-Muhit Fi Usul Fiqh. Misr: Dar Al-Kutbi.
Al-Zurqaniy, Muhammad ‘Abd Al-Azim. N.d. Manahil Al-Irfan Fi ‘Ulum Al-Quran. Misr: Matba‘ah ‘Isa Al-Babi Al-Halbi Wa Shirkah. Taba‘ah 3.
Published
2021-04-04
How to Cite
Said Mahmood, A. M. H., Wan Chik, W. M. Y., Mohamad, Z., & Daud, K. A. (2021). The Academic Improprieties Committed In Book Titled Al-Shafi’S Offence For Zakaria Ozone: Descriptive And Analytical Study. Al-Qanatir: International Journal of Islamic Studies, 22(1), 85-103. Retrieved from http://al-qanatir.com/index.php/aq/article/view/326